Subaru Outback Years an Automotive Technician Says to Avoid — Explore the Guide
MotorTrend writer and former automotive service technician Justin Banner flags the 2013, 2014, 2018, and 2020 Subaru Outback as years that call for extra caution when shopping used. His concerns include oil consumption, CVT behavior, battery drain, infotainment faults, and first-year electronics issues. His MotorTrend analysis also identifies alternatives within each generation, so buyers can compare specific vehicles rather than judge by year alone.
Who made the recommendations
Banner wrote MotorTrend’s Outback analysis, published June 12, 2026. MotorTrend’s author biography describes more than 15 years of automotive-industry experience, including work as an automotive service technician, Virginia State Inspector, service advisor, parts salesperson, and aftermarket technical advisor. That background supports describing him as an experienced automotive technician and automotive writer—not as a Subaru employee or as a spokesperson for mechanics generally. His recommendations are one writer’s assessment, not a consensus survey of technicians. (motortrend.com)
At the time of review, the MotorTrend page displays that June 12, 2026 publication date and discusses Outbacks from the 2010 model year through 2025. It does not extend its buying recommendations to the 2026 model. The year-by-year concerns below follow Banner’s assessment; official recall and settlement sources add context where applicable.
How the MotorTrend analysis assessed the Outback
Banner’s guide considers model years, engine and transmission configurations, reported trouble areas, and changes between generations. It is a practical shopping assessment, not a published failure-rate study. When the article discusses owner reports—such as screen problems or CVT symptoms—those reports should not be read as proof that every vehicle has the fault or as a manufacturer-confirmed defect rate.
The avoid list is specific: 2013 and 2014 in the 2010–2014 generation, 2018 in the 2015–2019 generation, and 2020 in the 2020–2025 generation. “Avoid” here is a shopping recommendation based on reported patterns and known trouble areas. It does not mean every example will fail, that a vehicle is unsafe by definition, or that a repaired and maintained car cannot be worth considering. The other side of that caution is important too: Banner’s preferred years are not guaranteed to be trouble-free.
2013 and 2014: investigate the engine and CVT history
In Banner’s MotorTrend assessment, the 2013 and 2014 Outback deserve scrutiny for two main reasons: concerns with early Lineartronic CVTs and oil consumption associated with the FB25B 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine.
The source describes owner reports of CVT shuddering and stalling linked to torque-converter and lock-up-clutch concerns. It also notes inadequate CVT cooling under demanding conditions, such as sustained climbs or towing. Separately, defective piston rings were associated with excessive oil use in the FB25B. These are risks to investigate, not evidence that every car from these years has the same condition.
A historical class-action settlement addressed excessive oil consumption in certain Subaru vehicles, including specified Outback configurations. Its coverage was not a blanket guarantee for every 2013 or 2014 Outback; engine, transmission, vehicle history, and settlement terms matter. The settlement notice describes the extended coverage for qualifying vehicles. A buyer should ask for records of any oil-consumption test, engine repair or replacement, and prior warranty work, then have an independent technician assess the engine and transmission. (govinfo.gov)
Banner points shoppers toward the 2012 Outback as the standout of this generation. For buyers seeking a manual, he also identifies 2010–2012 models with the EJ253 2.5-liter engine and six-speed manual as configurations to look for. The 2012 3.6-liter H-6 with its five-speed automatic is another combination the article describes as a durable alternative within the generation. Not every 2012 has that engine or transmission, and it is not problem-free simply because it is preferred in the guide.
2018: check the screen, battery, and transmission records
Banner flags the 2018 Outback chiefly for infotainment and electrical concerns. The touchscreen may delaminate, a condition associated with unintended or “ghost” touches. Screen operation should be tested across the display, including while using climate controls and other functions. Ask whether the unit has been replaced and whether repair documentation is available; an apparent screen fault can affect day-to-day usability and may add an ownership expense.
Another concern is battery drain that owners have attributed to the Data Communication Module (DCM), which may fail to enter sleep mode. Subaru technical information describes DCM-related battery-drain coverage for certain vehicles, but any extension depends on the individual vehicle and its eligibility. The Subaru technical bulletin explains the scope and conditions; it should not be taken to mean every 2018 Outback qualifies. If a DCM fuse is missing, treat it as a clue for a qualified technician to investigate—not as a diagnosis or a permanent repair. (static.nhtsa.gov)
The source also notes some CVT concerns and emphasizes consistent transmission maintenance. Ask for service records and have the technician evaluate operation, noises, hesitation, and shuddering. Do not assume a universal fluid-change interval from an online discussion: maintenance requirements can depend on the vehicle and how it has been used, so consult the applicable manufacturer information and a technician familiar with Subaru vehicles.
For an alternative in the same generation, Banner prefers the 2016 and 2017 Outback. He cites improvements after the 2015 generation launch, including revised piston rings in the FB25B, smoother CVT operation, suspension refinements that improved ride, and steering revisions. Those changes make these years a generation “sweet spot” in his assessment, but they do not eliminate every possible oil-consumption, transmission, electrical, or maintenance concern.
2020: inspect first-year electronics and powertrain updates
The 2020 Outback began the sixth generation, and Banner flags it as the year in that generation to approach carefully. His concerns include DCM-related battery drain; infotainment that lags, freezes, or goes blank; unresponsive climate controls; rearview-camera issues; windshield cracking reports; and rough or sluggish CVT behavior. An individual vehicle may already have received updates or repairs, so ask for records rather than assuming the work remains outstanding.
A recall addressed a rearview-camera display issue on certain 2020 Legacy and Outback vehicles. NHTSA’s recall record describes the potential for the display to fail; only a VIN lookup can establish whether a particular car was included and whether the remedy was completed. Subaru’s recall page and NHTSA’s recall lookup provide vehicle-specific searches. (static.nhtsa.gov)
Banner also describes a drive-chain recall involving certain turbo models and transmission-control-unit reprogramming, with transmission replacement in some cases if inspection found damage. The official Subaru recall service document describes the repair procedure for affected vehicles; not every 2020 Outback was included. The windshield concern also has current ownership context: Subaru’s notice identifies 2020–2022 Outbacks among vehicles covered by a limited extension for qualifying original-windshield cracks, subject to its terms. Any replacement involving the EyeSight cameras needs appropriate recalibration. The manufacturer’s windshield warranty-extension notice explains that coverage is conditional, not universal. (static.nhtsa.gov)
For a later sixth-generation alternative, Banner identifies 2021–2025 as preferable to the first-year 2020. He describes the later cars as more refined, with some early electronics and powertrain complaints resolved or reduced. They were offered with the 2.5-liter FB25D, while turbo versions use the 2.4-liter FA24F. Verify the exact configuration, service history, recall completion, and remaining warranty individually. Warranty status depends on factors such as the in-service date, mileage, and applicable terms; model year alone does not establish coverage.
How maintenance history can change the decision
A documented repair can meaningfully change the picture for an individual Outback. For the 2013–2014 models, records of oil-consumption testing, engine work, and CVT service help clarify what has been addressed. For a 2018, review battery and DCM diagnosis, screen replacement, and transmission maintenance. For a 2020, look for documentation of recall work, software updates, module replacement, windshield work, camera repair, and transmission inspection or repair.
A clean history report can help identify title or accident concerns, but it does not replace a mechanical inspection. Compare the asking price with the vehicle’s mileage, condition, maintenance gaps, immediate repair needs, tire wear, insurance and fuel costs, and transmission condition. Potential screen replacement, oil-consumption repairs, windshield replacement and EyeSight calibration can also affect ownership costs. No model year alone determines whether a particular car is a sensible purchase.
Pre-purchase inspection checklist
A professional pre-purchase inspection by a technician familiar with Subaru vehicles is especially useful for the years Banner flags. A practical inspection includes:
- Start the engine cold and note unusual noises, rough running, smoke, warning lights, or delayed starting.
- Check the oil level, look for leaks, and ask about oil use between changes and any engine work.
- Review service records for engine, CVT, battery, electrical, and scheduled maintenance work.
- Test the CVT in varied driving conditions for shuddering, hesitation, rough engagement, sluggish response, or unusual sounds.
- Test the infotainment touchscreen and climate controls; note delamination, freezing, blank areas, or unintended inputs.
- Check battery condition and ask a technician to investigate recurring battery drain, DCM behavior, or an absent DCM fuse.
- Inspect the windshield and confirm that any replacement was completed with the required EyeSight calibration.
- Confirm EyeSight operation and check for warning lights; verify camera and rearview-display function.
- Review open and completed recalls by the individual vehicle’s VIN using Subaru’s or NHTSA’s lookup tool.
- Inspect tire wear, wheel bearings, suspension, brakes, underbody corrosion, and accident and title history.
How to compare individual Outbacks
Start with the specific vehicle’s records and condition, then use Banner’s years as a guide to focus the inspection. Confirm the engine and transmission rather than assuming all trims share one configuration. For any recalled or warranty-related work, request paperwork and compare it with a VIN-specific lookup; a seller’s verbal assurance is not the same as a repair record.
The same-generation alternatives are 2012 or a 2010–2012 manual configuration, 2016–2017, and 2021–2025, according to Banner. Compare them on purchase price, mileage, maintenance, accident history, title, tires, likely near-term work, and remaining warranty eligibility. A newer or preferred model year can still be a poor match if its condition or records are weak; an avoid-listed year with documented repairs and careful maintenance should be judged as an individual car.
A practical conclusion
Banner’s caution list is precise: 2013, 2014, 2018, and 2020 Outbacks merit closer inspection for the concerns associated with their engines, CVTs, electrical systems, screens, cameras, and early production. The same MotorTrend guide names alternatives within each generation, including 2012, 2016–2017, and 2021–2025. Use those recommendations to narrow comparisons, then let service records, VIN-specific recall status, a professional inspection, and the vehicle’s total ownership needs determine whether an individual Outback deserves consideration.
Sources
- MotorTrend: Best Subaru Outback Years to Buy (and the Model Years to Avoid)
- MotorTrend author biography: Justin Banner
- Subaru Vehicle Recalls
- NHTSA recall lookup
- NHTSA-hosted Subaru drive-chain recall service document
- NHTSA-hosted Subaru rearview-camera recall announcement
- Oil-consumption settlement notice
- Subaru windshield warranty-extension notice